They argued that the company should not be regarded as the beneficiary of the aid since it is currently responsible only for operating the vessel, at its own risk, on behalf of the vessel's joint owners (private investors hold 99,73 % of the shares, with the rest being held by CIL). It will buy the vessel at its market value, but only if certain economic, legal and financial conditions are met. They also argued that, since the relevant legal framework was the Shipbuilding Aid Directive, the aid should be regarded as aid to shipbuilding and that in previous similar cases (and notably in its decision relating to Renaissance Financial(6) the Commission had considered the aid beneficiary to be the shipyard.
Recital 11, Decision_act (EU) 2001/882
In forcesince 25 Jul 2001