By the end of 1993, the cost of restructuring NL and EGL amounted to DM 177,4 million (investments in machinery, buildings and infrastructure, negative cash flows, and changes in working capital). To this amount must be added a further DM 62,5 million invested by MB in the years 1994 and 1995 in upgrading installations, land rehabilitation and social costs for voluntary redundancies. Consequently, the restructuring costs are much higher than originally foreseen. The total amount for the period 1991 to 1995 was DM 239,9 million.
Mercedes-Benz purchased the remaining shares of FBG with effect from 1 January 1994 for a total of DM 7,875 million. In line with the sales contract, MB paid DM 476 000 to the THA in 1994 for provisions made previously and which had not been necessary and had therefore been released. In addition, it purchased for DM 55 million the land and buildings previously rented by NL.
While the sales price for land and buildings in 1994 was not established on the basis of an independent evaluation but was the result of negotiations between THA/IFA and MB after a second bidder who had pre-emption rights on the plot dropped out of the negotiations, the price per square metre was probably higher than that for comparable plots on the Ludwigsfelde site previously sold by IFA to other private companies, when market prices were considerably higher. Furthermore, the agreement stipulates that, if MB resells or rents out part of the land for a higher price, a revaluation will have to be carried out and an additional payment made to THA of the difference in excess of 7 %.
After the investment and privatization, NL and the holding company FBG have been profitable since 1994, as only one product is now being produced while, with the installation of a paint shop for the Kastenwagen variant of the T2, transport costs have fallen and efficiency has increased. Furthermore, since transfer prices are based on total costs at comparable sites, the reduction in production volume (see below) has improved NL's earnings per truck.
VI
In assessing a case, the Commission must first consider which measures taken by the authorities of a Member State contain State aid elements and which are caught by the State aid provisions of Article 92 of the Treaty.