, Decision_act (EU) 1997/13

In forcesince 26 Jun 1996

The German Government explained by letter dated 29 May 1991 that, in its view, the Community framework did not apply to the new German Laender between 1 January and 31 March 1991 because it had been due to expire by the end of 1990 and its renewal by the Commission in December 1990 could become legally binding only upon formal acceptance of the prolongation by the German Government or upon a formal decision of the Commission pursuant to the Article 93 (2) procedure. However, given that the aid measures in question were approved before 31 March 1991, they could be scrutinized by the Commission only with reference to the approved regional aid schemes for the new Laender.

The legal position taken by the German Government was not accepted by the Commission, on the following grounds:

1.

the Decision of 21 February 1990 on the applicability of the Community framework in question to Germany, which was not challenged by the German Government, was not limited in time, and hence its renewal by the Commission in December 1990 did not affect the fundamental notification requirement;

2.

the German Government did not challenge or react to the renewal of the Framework itself so the Commission could legitimately assume it would comply with the applicable provisions;

3.

when approving the extension of existing regional aid schemes to the new Laender (3), the Commission stipulated that Community frameworks should be complied with. That extension means that the provisions of the 19th outline plan for the joint Federal Government/Laender scheme, which was published by the German Government in July 1991 and approved by Commission letter SG(90) D/27707 of 2 October 1991, must also be complied with in the case of aid cases in the new Laender. Hence the prior notification requirement for State aid to the motor vehicle industry applies in these cases too.

Consequently, the Commission considered these cases as non-notified cases, given that the aid was approved by the German authorities before prior agreement by the Commission.

The decision to initiate the Article 93 (2) procedure was based on a first detailed analysis of the information contained in the German authorities' letters of 16 September and 10 December 1991 and of several bilateral contacts with representatives of the German authorities.