, Decision_act (EU) 1997/13

In forcesince 26 Jun 1996

The Commission is considering authorizing restructuring aid totalling DM 124,32 million. In view of the reduction in capacity from 35 000 trucks per year when the aid was granted, to the current level of 18 000 trucks per year, this represents an appropriate contribution to resolving the structural problems of the sector as a whole. This is in line with the approach taken by the Commission in former cases of restructuring aid - see Decisions 88/454/EEC (Renault) (OJ No L 220, 11. 8. 1988, p. 30), 89/58/EEC (Rover) (OJ No L 25, 28. 1. 1989, p. 92), 89/633/EEC (Enasa) (OJ No L 367, 16. 12. 1989, p. 62), and 94/1068/EC (Volkswagen Sachsen) (OJ No L 385, 31. 12. 1994, p. 1) - where restructuring aid was considered to be in proportion to the restructuring effort if the share of the aid in the total restructuring costs of the company (DM 239,9 million over the period 1991 to 1995) was approximately equivalent to the scale of capacity reductions undertaken. In the case of NL, the share of the aid (51,8 %) slightly exceeds the relative capacity reduction (48,6 %). This slight overcompensation is, in the Commission's opinion, justified by the particularly difficult economic and social conditions in the new Laender, which in the meantime have been recognized as assisted areas pursuant to Article 92 (3) (a). A similar overcompensation was also accepted by the Commission in the Volkswagen Sachsen case.

Accordingly, the restructuring aid to FBG is considered by the Commission to be appropriate to its objective, namely the restructuring of the company that was successfully completed at the end of 1995. Nevertheless, the Commission has established, on the basis of an independent valuation, that the sales price paid by MB for the THA's shares is below their market value and thus contains an element of State aid.

This additional aid of 8,6 million is thus disproportionate to the expenditure incurred and is not justified by regional considerations. If anything, therefore, it resembles operating aid, which, under the Community framework, can under no circumstances be allowed. The same holds for any additional aid which may be requested by MB in connection with the investments made by it since full privatization of FBG and before the end of the restructuring plan.