34 ASSESSMENT OF THE REVISED PERFORMANCE TARGETS DURING THE DETAILED EXAMINATION › Assessment of the revised performance targets on the basis of the assessment criteria set out in points 1.4 (a), (b) and (c) of Annex IV to Implementing Regulation 2019/317 › Findings on the determined costs for the charging zone, broken down per ANSP › Specific observations regarding skeyes, Decision_act (EU) 2023/1336

In forcesince 16 Jun 2023

In respect of skeyes, which has the largest proportion of determined costs in the charging zone, the Commission has received additional benchmarking analysis from the PRB. That analysis shows that the relative cost-efficiency performance of skeyes has deteriorated in comparison with LVNL [‘Air Traffic Control the Netherlands’ (LVNL).], which has a very similar operational environment and which is included in the same comparator group for the purpose of assessing performance targets in the key performance area of cost-efficiency [As set out in Article 6 of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/891.]. At the end of RP2, the unit cost of skeyes for 2019 was 2,2 % higher than the unit cost of LVNL. [The unit costs of skeyes and LVNL both exclude the service units attributable to MUAC within their respective charging zones. The unit costs for skeyes and LVNL cover all the en route air navigation services, including meteorological services (MET) which in the Netherlands are provided by a MET provider separate from LVNL.] By the end of RP3, in 2024, after adjusting the unit cost of skeyes for the one-off cost reduction of 6,5 million EUR (in EUR 2017) referred to in recital (30), the unit cost of skeyes is expected to be higher by 9,4 % than the unit cost of LVNL.