This Annex shall apply for dual-fuel engines as defined in Article 3(18) of Regulation (EU) 2016/1628 when they are being operated simultaneously on both a liquid and a gaseous fuel (dual-fuel mode).
This Annex shall not apply for testing engines, including dual-fuel engines, when they are being operated solely on liquid or solely on gaseous fuels (i.e. when the GER is either 1 or 0 according to the type of fuel). In this case the requirements are the same as for any single-fuel engine.
Type approval of engines operated simultaneously on a combination of more than one liquid fuel and a gaseous fuel or a liquid fuel and more than one gaseous fuel shall follow the procedure for new technologies or new concepts given in Article 33 of Regulation (EU) 2016/1628.
For the purposes of this Annex the following definitions shall apply:
2.1. ‘GER (Gas Energy Ratio)’ has the meaning defined in Article 3(20) of Regulation (EU) 2016/1628 based on the lower heating value;
2.2. ‘GERcycle’ means the average GER when operating the engine on the applicable engine test cycle;
2.3. ‘Dual-fuel Type 1A engine’ means either:
a dual-fuel engine of a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRTC, hot ≥ 0,9) and that does not idle using exclusively liquid fuel, and that has no liquid-fuel mode, or;
a dual-fuel engine of any (sub-) category other than a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRSC ≥ 0,9) and that does not idle using exclusively liquid fuel, and that has no liquid-fuel mode;
2.4. ‘Dual-Fuel Type 1B engine’ means either:
a dual-fuel engine of a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRTC, hot ≥ 0,9) and that does not idle using exclusively liquid fuel in dual-fuel mode, and that has a liquid-fuel mode, or;
a dual-fuel engine of any (sub-) category other than a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRSC ≥ 0,9) and that does not idle using exclusively liquid fuel in dual-fuel mode, and that has a liquid-fuel mode;
2.5. ‘Dual-Fuel Type 2A engine’ means either:
a dual-fuel engine of a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio between 10 % and 90 % (0,1 < GERNRTC, hot < 0,9) and that has no liquid-fuel mode or that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRTC, hot ≥ 0,9), but that idles using exclusively liquid fuel, and that has no liquid-fuel mode, or;
a dual-fuel engine of any (sub-) category other than a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio between 10 % and 90 % (0,1 < GERNRSC < 0,9), and that has no liquid-fuel mode or that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRSC ≥ 0,9), but that idles using exclusively liquid fuel, and that has no liquid-fuel mode;
2.6. ‘Dual-Fuel Type 2B engine’ means either:
a dual-fuel engine of a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio between 10 % and 90 % (0,1 < GERNRTC, hot < 0,9) and that has a liquid-fuel mode or that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRTC, hot ≥ 0,9), and that has a liquid-fuel mode but that can idle using exclusively liquid fuel in dual-fuel mode, or;
a dual-fuel engine of any (sub-) category other than a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio between 10 % and 90 % (0,1 < GERNRSC < 0,9), and that has no liquid-fuel mode or that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio that is not lower than 90 % (GERNRSC ≥ 0,9), and that has a liquid-fuel mode but that can idle using exclusively liquid fuel in dual-fuel mode;
2.7. ‘Dual-Fuel Type 3B engine’ means either:
a dual-fuel engine of a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the hot-start NRTC test-cycle with an average gas energy ratio that does not exceed 10 % (GERNRTC, hot ≤ 0,1) and that has a liquid-fuel mode, or:
a dual-fuel engine of any (sub-) category other than a sub-category of NRE 19 ≤ kW ≤ 560, that operates over the NRSC with an average gas energy ratio that does not exceed 10 % (GERNRSC ≤ 0,1) and that has a liquid-fuel mode;
In the case for a given engine type the value of GERcycle can be reduced from the maximum by an operator-adjustable control, the minimum GERcycle shall not be limited but the engine shall be capable of meeting the emission limit values at any value of GERcycle permitted by the manufacturer.
A dual-fuel engine may only operate in liquid-fuel mode if, when operating in liquid-fuel mode, it has been certified according to all the requirements of this Regulation concerning operation solely on the specified liquid fuel.
When a dual-fuel engine is developed from an already certified liquid-fuel engine, then a new EU type approval certificate is required in the liquid-fuel mode.
4.1.2.1.
Dual-fuel Type 1A engines shall not idle using liquid fuel exclusively except under the conditions defined in point 4.1.3 for warm-up and start.
4.1.2.2.
Dual-fuel Type 1B engines shall not idle using liquid fuel exclusively in dual-fuel mode.
4.1.2.3.
Dual-fuel Types 2A, 2B and 3B engines may idle using liquid fuel exclusively.
4.1.3.1.
A Type 1B, Type 2B, or Type 3B dual-fuel engine may warm-up or start using liquid fuel solely. In the case that the emission control strategy during warm-up or start-up in dual-fuel mode is the same as the corresponding emission control strategy in liquid-fuel mode the engine may operate in dual-fuel mode during warm-up or start-up. If this condition is not met the engine shall only warm-up or start-up using liquid fuel solely when in liquid-fuel mode.
4.1.3.2.
A Type 1A or Type 2A dual-fuel engine may warm-up or start-up using liquid fuel solely. However, in that case, the strategy shall be declared as an AECS and the following additional requirements shall be met:
4.1.3.2.1.
The strategy shall cease to be active when the coolant temperature has reached a temperature of 343 K (70 °C), or within 15 minutes after it has been activated, whichever occurs first; and
4.1.3.2.2.
The service mode shall be activated while the strategy is active.
When an engine is operating in service mode it is subject to an operability restriction and is temporarily exempted from complying with the requirements related to exhaust emissions and NOx control described in this Regulation.
The operability restriction applicable to non-road mobile machinery fitted with a dual-fuel engine of engine categories other than IWP, IWA, RLL and RLR operated in service mode is the one activated by the ‘severe inducement system’ specified in point 5.4 of Appendix 1 of Annex IV.
In order to account for safety concerns and to allow for self-healing diagnostics, use of an inducement override function for releasing full engine power is permitted according to point 5.5 of Appendix 1 of Annex IV.
The operability restriction shall not otherwise be deactivated by either the activation or deactivation of the warning and inducement systems specified in Annex IV.
The activation and the deactivation of the service mode shall not activate or deactivate the warning and inducement systems specified in Annex IV.
For engines of category IWP, IWA, RLL and RLR, in order to account for safety concerns operation in service mode shall be permitted without limitation on engine torque or speed. In this case whenever an operability restriction would have been active according to point 4.2.2.3 the on-board computer log shall record in non-volatile computer memory all incidents of engine operation where the service mode is active in a manner to ensure that the information cannot be intentionally deleted.
It shall be possible for national inspection authorities to read these records with a scan tool. A description of the connection for, and method to read, those records shall be included in the information folder as set out in Part A of Annex I of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/656.
The operability restriction shall be automatically activated when the service mode is activated.
In the case where the service mode is activated according to point 4.2.3 because of a malfunction of the gas supply system, the operability restriction shall become active within 30 minutes operating time after the service mode is activated.
In the case where the service mode is activated because of an empty gaseous fuel tank, the operability restriction shall become active as soon as the service mode is activated.
The operability restriction system shall be deactivated when the engine no longer operates in service mode.
In order to permit the non-road mobile machinery to move to a position of safety, upon detection of an empty gaseous fuel tank, or of a malfunctioning gas supply system:
Dual-fuel engines of Types 1A and 2A shall activate the service mode;
Dual-fuel engines of Types 1B, 2B and 3B shall operate in liquid mode.
In the case of an empty gaseous fuel tank, the service mode or, as appropriate according to point 4.2.3, the liquid fuel mode shall be activated as soon as the engine system has detected that the tank is empty.
When the gas availability in the tank again reaches the level that justified the activation of the empty tank warning system specified in point 4.3.2, the service mode may be deactivated, or, when appropriate, the dual-fuel mode may be reactivated.
In the case of a malfunctioning gas supply system that causes the unavailability of gaseous fuel, the service mode or, as appropriate according to point 4.2.3, the liquid fuel mode shall be activated when gaseous fuel supply is not available.
As soon as the gaseous fuel supply becomes available the service mode may be deactivated, or, when appropriate, the dual-fuel mode may be reactivated.
The non-road mobile machinery shall provide to the operator a visual indication of the mode under which the engine operates (dual-fuel mode, liquid mode, or service mode).
The characteristics and the location of this indicator shall be left to the discretion of the OEM and may be part of an already existing visual indication system.
This indicator may be completed by a message display. The system used for displaying the messages referred to in this point may be the same as the ones used for NOx control diagnostics, or other maintenance purposes.
The visual element of the dual-fuel operating mode indicator shall not be the same as the one used for the purpose of NOx control diagnostics, or for other engine maintenance purposes.
Safety alerts always have display priority over the operating mode indication.
4.3.1.1.
The dual-fuel mode indicator shall be set to service mode as soon as the service mode is activated (i.e. before it becomes actually active) and the indication shall remain as long as the service mode is active.
4.3.1.2.
The dual-fuel mode indicator shall be set for at least one minute on dual-fuel mode or liquid-fuel mode as soon as the engine operating mode is changed from liquid fuel to dual-fuel mode or vice-versa. This indication is also required for at least one minute at key-on, or at the request of the manufacturer at engine cranking. The indication shall also be given upon the operator's request.
Non-road mobile machinery fitted with a dual-fuel engine shall be equipped with a dual-fuel warning system that alerts the operator that the gaseous fuel tank will soon become empty.
The dual-fuel warning system shall remain active until the tank is refuelled to a level above which the warning system is activated.
The dual-fuel warning system may be temporarily interrupted by other warning signals providing important safety-related messages.
It shall not be possible to turn off the dual-fuel warning system by means of a scan-tool as long as the cause of the warning activation has not been rectified.
The dual-fuel warning system shall consist of a visual alert system (icon, pictogram, etc.) left to the choice of the manufacturer.
It may include, at the choice of the manufacturer, an audible component. In that case, the cancelling of that component by the operator is permitted.
The visual element of the dual-fuel warning system shall not be the same as the one used for the purpose of NOx control diagnostics, or for other engine maintenance purposes.
In addition the dual-fuel warning system may display short messages, including messages indicating clearly the remaining distance or time before the activation of the operability restriction.
The system used for displaying the warning or messages referred to in this point may be the same as the one used for displaying the warning or messages related the NOx control diagnostics, or warning or messages for other maintenance purposes.
A facility to permit the operator to dim the visual alarms provided by the warning system may be provided on non-road mobile machinery for use by the rescue services or on non-road mobile machinery designed and constructed for use by the armed services, civil defense, fire services and forces responsible for maintaining public order.
When a dual-fuel engine operates in dual-fuel mode:
The reference torque curve retrievable shall be the one obtained when that engine is tested on an engine test bench in the dual-fuel mode;
The recorded actual torques (indicated torque and friction torque) shall be the result of the dual-fuel combustion and not the one obtained when operating with liquid fuel exclusively.
When a dual-fuel engine operates in liquid-fuel mode, the reference torque curve retrievable shall be the one obtained when the engine is tested on an engine test bench in liquid-fuel mode.
4.5.1.
Where used for a dual-fuel engine, adaptive strategies shall, in addition to satisfying the requirements of Annex IV, additionally comply with the following requirements:
The engine shall always remain within the dual-fuel engine type (that is Type 1A, Type 2B, etc.) that has been declared for EU type-approval; and
In case of a Type 2 engine, the resulting difference between the highest and the lowest maximum GERcycle within the family shall never exceed the range set out in point 2.4.15 of Annex IX to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/656, except as permitted by point 3.1.
4.6
The type-approval shall be conditional upon providing to the OEM and end-users, as required by in accordance with Annexes XIV and XV, instructions for installation and operation of the dual-fuel engine including the service mode set out in point 4.2 and the dual-fuel indicator system set out in point 4.3.
5.1.
The performance requirements, including emission limit values, and the requirements for EU type-approval applicable to dual-fuel engines are identical to those of any other engine of the respective engine category as set out in this Regulation and in Regulation (EU) 2016/1628, except as set out in this Annex.
5.2
The hydrocarbon (HC) limit for operation in dual-fuel mode shall be determined using the average gas energy ratio (GER) over the specified test cycle as set out in Annex II to Regulation (EU) 2016/1628.
5.3
The technical requirements on emission control strategies, including documentation required to demonstrate these strategies, technical provisions to resist tampering and the prohibition of defeat devices are identical to those of any other engine of the respective engine category as set out in Annex IV.
5.4
The detailed technical requirements on the area associated with the relevant NRSC, within which there is control of the amount that the emissions shall be permitted to exceed the limit values set out in Annex II to Regulation (EU) 2016/1628 are identical to those of any other engine of the respective engine category as set out in Annex IV.
6.1.
The demonstration requirements applicable to dual-fuel engines are identical to those of any other engine of the respective engine category as set out in this Regulation and in Regulation (EU) 2016/1628, except as set out in section 6.
6.2.
Compliance with the applicable limit values shall be demonstrated in dual-fuel mode.
6.3.
For dual-fuel engine types with a liquid-fuel mode (i.e. types 1B, 2B, 3B) compliance with the applicable limit values shall additionally be demonstrated in liquid-fuel mode.
6.4.1
The manufacturer shall present the approval authority with evidence showing that the GERcycle span of all members of the dual-fuel engine family remains within the range set out in point 2.4.15 of Annex IX to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/656, or in the case of engines with an operator-adjustable GERcycle satisfy the requirements of point 6.5 (for example, through algorithms, functional analyses, calculations, simulations, results of previous tests, etc.).
6.5.1
Compliance with the applicable limit values shall be demonstrated at the minimum and maximum value of GERcycle permitted by the manufacturer.
6.6.1
Provisions of Annex III shall apply.
6.7.1
As part of the application for EU type-approval under this Regulation, the manufacturer shall demonstrate the operation of dual-fuel indicators and of the warning and operability restriction in accordance with the provisions of Appendix 1.
A demonstration report shall document the demonstration conducted pursuant to points 6.1 to 6.7.1 The report shall:
describe the demonstration performed, including the applicable test cycle;
be included in the information folder as set out in Part A of Annex I of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2017/656.
7.1.
Annex IV (technical requirements on NOx control measures) shall apply to dual-fuel engines, whether operating in dual-fuel or liquid mode.
7.2.1.
The torque considered to apply to the severe inducement defined in point 5.4 of Appendix 1 of Annex IV shall be the lowest of the torques obtained in liquid-fuel mode and in dual-fuel mode.
7.2.2
A possible influence of the mode of operation on the malfunction detection shall not be used to extend the time until an inducement becomes active.
7.2.3.
In the case of malfunctions the detection of which does not depend on the operation mode of the engine, the mechanisms specified in Appendix 1 of Annex IV that are associated with the DTC status shall not depend on the operation mode of the engine (for example, if a DTC reached the potential status in dual-fuel mode, it will get the confirmed and active status the next time the failure is detected, even in liquid-fuel mode).
7.2.4.
In the case of malfunctions where the detection depends on the operation mode of the engine, DTCs shall not get a previously active status in a different mode than the mode in which they reached the confirmed and active status.
7.2.5.
A change of the mode of operation (dual-fuel to liquid fuel or vice-versa) shall not stop nor reset the mechanisms implemented to comply with the requirements set out in Annex IV (e.g. counters). However, in the case where one of these mechanisms (for example a diagnostic system) depends on the actual operation mode the counter associated with that mechanism may, at the request of the manufacturer and upon approval of the approval authority:
Halt and, when applicable, hold their present value when the operation mode changes;
Restart and, when applicable, continue counting from the point at which they have been held when the operation mode changes backs to the other operation mode.
The ability of the engine to command the activation of the dual-fuel mode indicator when operating in dual-fuel mode shall be demonstrated at EU type-approval.
In the case of a Type 1B, Type 2B, or Type 3B dual-fuel engine the ability of the engine to command the activation of the liquid-fuel mode indicator when operating in liquid-fuel mode shall be demonstrated at EU type-approval.
The ability of the engine to command the activation of the service mode indicator when operating in service mode shall be demonstrated at EU type-approval.
1.3.1.
When so-equipped it is sufficient to perform the demonstration related to the service mode indicator by activating a service mode activation switch and to present the approval authority with evidence showing that the activation occurs when the service mode is commanded by the engine system itself (for example, through algorithms, simulations, result of in-house tests, etc. …).
The ability of the engine to command the activation of the warning system in the case that the amount of gaseous fuel in the gaseous fuel tank is below the warning level, shall be demonstrated at EU type-approval. For that purpose the actual amount of gaseous fuel may be simulated.
In the case of a Type 1A or Type 2A dual-fuel engine the ability of the engine to command the activation of the operability restriction upon detection of an empty gaseous fuel tank and of a malfunctioning gas supply system shall be demonstrated at EU type-approval. For that purpose the empty gaseous fuel tank and the malfunctioning of the gas supply may be simulated.
3.1.
It is sufficient to perform the demonstration in a typical use-case selected with the agreement of the approval authority and to present that authority with evidence showing that the operability restriction occurs in the other possible use-cases (for example, through algorithms, simulations, result of in-house tests, etc.).
This point defines the additional requirements and exceptions of this Annex to enable emission testing of dual-fuel engines independent whether these emissions are solely exhaust emissions or also crankcase emissions added to the exhaust emissions according to point 6.10 of Annex VI. In the case that no additional requirement or exception is listed, the requirements of this Regulation shall apply to dual-fuel engines in the same way as they apply to any other approved engine types or engine families under Regulation (EU) 2016/1628.
Emission testing of a dual-fuel engine is complicated by the fact that the fuel used by the engine can vary between pure liquid fuel and a combination of mainly gaseous fuel with only a small amount of liquid fuel as an ignition source. The ratio between the fuels used by a dual-fuel engine can also change dynamically depending of the operating condition of the engine. As a result special precautions and restrictions are necessary to enable emission testing of these engines.