After it had decided that Romania had breached the BIT, the Tribunal explained that damages had to be awarded on the basis of the principle that ‘the claimant must be placed back in the position it would have been “in all probability” but for the international wrong’ [Award, paragraph 917.]. It further explained that only losses that are causally linked to the act constituting the international wrong could be compensated by means of damages, and that ‘all of the violations of the BIT alleged by the Claimants arise from the same fact: the premature revocation of the [EGO 24] incentives or in direct connection with that premature revocation’ [Award, paragraph 928.]. In assessing the precise compensation due to the claimants, the Tribunal took into account whether losses were in reality incurred and whether they were directly related to the revocation of the incentive scheme. For instance, with regard to the damages awarded for the increased price of sugar, the Tribunal held [Award, paragraph 953.]: ‘Both the existence of the damage and the causal link between the revocation of the incentives and the damage suffered have been adequately proved. There is no dispute that, as a result of the revocation of the Raw Materials Incentive, the Claimants were required to pay an increased amount for the sugar they purchased after February 2005’.
94 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of aid › Economic advantage (1), Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470
In forcesince 30 Mar 2015cited 1×
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 2 October 2024 (Extracts). European Food SA and Others v European CoDecision
It is apparent from recital 94 of the contested decision that the Commission considered, first of all, that the arbitral tribunal had compensated the damage resulting from the premature repeal of the tax incentives scheme at issue. The …
2 Oct 2024 · 62015TJ0624(01)