156 8. RECOVERY, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470

In forcesince 30 Mar 2015

According to the case-law of the CJEU, save in exceptional circumstances, undertakings to which an aid has been granted may not, in principle, entertain a legitimate expectation that the aid is lawful unless it has been granted in compliance with the procedure laid down in Article 108(3) of the Treaty. The CJEU, in its more recent case-law, has declared that in the absence of sufficiently precise assurances arising from a positive action taken by the Commission, which has the exclusive competence to authorise the grant of State aid by the Member States of the Union, that lead the beneficiary to believe that the measure does not constitute State aid, no exceptional circumstances can warrant the application of the principle of the protection of legitimate expectations to prevent recovery if that aid measure was not notified to the Commission [Case C-148/04 Unicredito Italiano EU:C:2005:774, paragraphs 104 to 111.]. Indeed, it is long-standing case-law that the principle of the protection of legitimate expectations cannot be relied upon against a precise provision of Union law and that the conduct of a national authority responsible for applying Union law, which acts in breach of that law, cannot give rise to legitimate expectations on the part of an economic operator that he will benefit from treatment which is contrary to that law [Judgment in Case C-217/06 Commission v Italy EU:C:2007:580, point 23 and the case-law cited.]. A diligent economic operator must be assumed to be able to determine whether that procedure has been followed [Case C-5/89 Commission v Germany EU:C:1990:320, paragraph 14.].

  • Judgment of the Court of 20 September 1990. Commission of the European Communities v Federal Republic of Germany.Decision

    20 Sep 1990 · 61989CJ0005

  • Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 15 December 2005. Unicredito Italiano SpA v Agenzia delle Entrate, Ufficio Genova 1.Decision

    15 Dec 2005 · 62004CJ0148

  • Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 4 October 2007. Commission of the European Communities v Italian Republic.Decision

    4 Oct 2007 · 62006CJ0217

  • Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union108Law