Finally, every act of Romania’s state organs is imputable to Romania. Those state organs include the Member State’s government and other public authorities. Notably, also domestic courts of a state and court-appointed executors and bailiffs are to be considered organs of that state and are thus bound under Article 4(3) of the Treaty on European Union by their duty of sincere cooperation vis-à-vis the Union. Accordingly, the actions of domestic courts and court-appointed executors and bailiffs are imputable to the Romanian state, so that if Romania is compelled to compensate the claimants under the Award by the action of its courts or court-appointed executors and bailiffs, that action is also imputable to the Romanian state. Union law recognises only a narrow exemption from this general principle of imputability: a measure is not imputable to a Member State if that Member State is under an obligation under Union law to implement that measure without any discretion. In that case, the measure stems from an act of the Union legislature and is not imputable to the State. It is, however, undisputed that Romania is not obliged by Union law to implement the Award. Any decision to implement or execute the Award, whether taken by the Romanian government or Romania’s domestic courts, is thus imputable to the Romanian State
120 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of aid › Imputability, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470
In forcesince 30 Mar 2015cited 1×
Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 2 October 2024 (Extracts). European Food SA and Others v European CoDecision
In recitals 118 to 120 of the contested decision, the Commission stated, first of all, that Romania’s voluntary agreement to enter into the BIT created the favourable conditions for the selective advantage.
2 Oct 2024 · 62015TJ0624(01)