102 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of aid › Economic advantage (2): damages and State aid, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470

In forcesince 30 Mar 2015

Second, for compensation to fall outside the Union State aid rules under the Asteris case-law it must be based on a general rule of compensation [See Commission Decision of 16 June 2004 on Dutch aid in favour of Akzo-Nobel in order to minimise chlorine transports (Case N 304/2003), summary notice in OJ C 81, 2.4.2005, p. 4; see also Commission Decision of 20 December 2006 on Dutch aid for relocation of car dismantling company Steenbergen (Case N 575/05), summary notice in OJ C 80, 13.4.2007, p. 1.]. In the present case, the compensation has been awarded to the claimants on the basis of an intra-EU BIT which the Commission considers invalid as of Romania’s accession to the Union. The Commission has consistently taken the view that intra-EU BITs, such as the BIT upon which the claimants base their claim [For the same reasons, the Commission would also consider invalid the intra-EU BITs at the basis of the arbitral proceedings listed in footnote 53 of the application.], are contrary to Union law since they are incompatible with provisions of the Union Treaties and should therefore be considered invalid [See response of Commissioner De Gucht to Parliamentary oral Question O-000043/2013/rev.1 in which he stated ‘The Commission agrees that bilateral and investment treaties (BITS) between EU Member States do not comply with EU law’, debate of the plenary of 22 May 2013. See, further, Commission Staff Working Document of 3 February 2012 on capital movements and investments in the EU — Commission Services’ Paper on Market Monitoring, SWD(2012)6 final, page 13. See also, Commission Staff Working Document of 15 April 2013 on the free movement of capital in the EU, SWD(2013)146 final, pages 11 and 14; Commission Staff Working Document of 18 March 2014 on the free movement of capital in the EU, SWD(2014)115 final, page 12; and European Commission, Monitoring activities and analysis, Bilateral Investment Treaties between EU Member States (intra-EU BITs) 2012; available at: http://ec.europa.eu/internal_market/capital/analysis/monitoring_activities_and_analysis/index_en.htm]. The Commission has repeatedly made this view known to the Member States, including the Member States in question.