To substantiate its claim that obligations were imposed on it, Buonotourist argued that the PSOs were not set out in the document awarding the concession, which did not exist, but derived solely from internal acts of the Region which predetermined the organisation of the undertaking and the compensation through the ‘standard cost’ mechanism. Buonotourist explained that Italy had regulated the PSOs by means of Law No 151/81, Regional Law No 16/83, Article 4 of Law No 59/97 and Legislative Decree No 422/97. The public service was entrusted to Buonotourist by the Region by means of a concession act in 1972/73 and renewed every year until 2003. That PSOs were imposed on Buonotourist for the years 1996-2002, such as tariff obligations, routes, times and stops, can be allegedly inferred from the following documents:
the ‘bridging service contract’ signed by Buonotourist and the Region for the year 2003 in compliance with Article 46 of Regional Law No 3/02, recalling and replacing the existing concessions,
decision of the Regional Government (delibera della Giunta Regionale) No 8726 of 30 December 1999, authorising Buonotourist to modify some routes following requests from both the company and other petitioners,
decision of the Regional Government No 323 of 4 May 2000, which extended the duration of the suspension of the increase in costs for season tickets for bus transport services in the Region,
note 4770/2000 communicating the distinction between how to calculate the tariff for ordinary season tickets and season tickets for ‘work lines’ (linee operaie),
decree of the Region’s Assessore di Trasporti No 1609/2001 concerning the change from lira to euros, reminding the service providers that any irregular increase in tariffs was forbidden and that prohibition constituted a ‘concession/contractual obligation’.