46 4. COMMENTS BY INTERESTED PARTIES, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1075

In forcesince 19 Jan 2015

Concerning the correctness of the calculation method and its consistency with Union law, Buonotourist considered that the company had to be compensated for the disadvantage incurred in terms of the difference between lower revenue and greater costs as a consequence of its PSOs. To establish the value of lower revenue on the basis of reliable data, Buonotourist, first, considered the actual annual operating revenue, which was the product of the actual number of units of measure of transport and the tariff imposed. It then identified the amount to be subtracted in accordance with Union rules, considering the revenue necessary to cover the actual costs as recorded in the annual accounts. The amount of the annual operating revenue coincides with the actual revenue obtained by the company in the activity provided under a tariff obligation which was separately indicated in the annual financial statements of Buonotourist and in the E forms sent each year to the Region, which never questioned their reliability. There is, therefore, no need to break down those amounts into their component parts, even though they include revenues for routes that were not subject to concessions and are therefore overstated. As for the amount to be subtracted, Buonotourist claimed that it used a criterion that fully complied with the instructions contained in Regulation (EEC) No 1191/69, which allowed the use of the tariff that the company would have applied had it operated on a commercial basis, which had to cover the actual costs incurred. As far as the difference between the costs which the undertaking would have incurred by applying the most favourable existing rate or operating on a commercial basis and the costs actually incurred were concerned, Buonotourist considered that its calculation is fully consistent with Article 11 of that Regulation, as it captured the lower cost incurred by the undertaking as a consequence of the PSO on account of the contributions received from the Region to cover operating costs. Moreover, Buonotourist is of the opinion that it would be impossible to estimate the passenger traffic in a free market scenario. Therefore the ‘inductive method’ prescribed by the Consiglio di Stato is legitimate. Finally, Buonotourist recalled that both Articles 10 and 11 established the right of public transport companies subject to PSOs to be compensated for all negative financial impacts resulting from their obligations.

  • celex=31969R1191