76 6. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 6.2. EXEMPTION FROM THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION UNDER REGULATION (EEC) NO 1191/69 › (i) PSO unilaterally imposed, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1075

In forcesince 19 Jan 2015

The Italian authorities claim that the sample concession contract provided by them — which concerned another undertaking — was the standard one in use in the Region during the period under review. However, the sample concession contract was only valid from April 1972 to December 1973, which is more than 20 years before the period under review, and before the entry into force of Law No 151/1981, as enacted by Regional Law No 16/1983, on which basis Buonotourist was compensated in the first instance. Although the sample concession contract would seem to provide for some obligations that could qualify as PSOs (e.g. at points 2, 9 and 10), including the duty to apply discounts for students, workers, teachers, and private and public employees and the duty to transport certain categories of passengers for free, the Commission has no evidence that the same obligations were actually applicable to Buonotourist during the period under review because of the absence of an entrustment act. Rather, considering that the services provided were regular scheduled services, it was necessary for the concession regulations, which granted Buonotourist an exclusive right to provide those services, to specify in advance the arrangements for the services to be provided. Buonotourist has not provided evidence to show that those arrangements were unilaterally imposed by the Region, instead of being proposed by the operator, in return for the right to provide services on an exclusive basis, and subsequently authorised by the Region. In any case, the methodology used by the court-appointed expert to calculate the alleged undercompensation does not refer to those obligations.