The Commission notes in this respect that, under certain circumstances, compensation for damages due to the wrongful acts or other conduct by the national authorities [For example, tort or unjust enrichment.] does not provide for an advantage and is therefore not to be considered State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) of the Treaty [Joined Cases 106 to 120/87, Asteris and others v Greece and EEC, [1988] EU:C:1988:457.]. The purpose of compensation for damage suffered is different from that of State aid since it aims to bring the damaged party back to the situation in which it found itself prior to the damaging act, as if the latter had not occurred (restitutio in integrum). The Commission further notes, in that respect, that for compensation for damages to fall outside the State aid rules, it must be based on a general rule of compensation [See Commission Decision of 16 June 2004 on Dutch aid in favour of Akzo Nobel in order to minimise chlorine transports (Case N 304/2003), summary notice in OJ C 81, 2.4.2005, p. 4; See also Commission Decision of 20 December 2006 on Dutch aid for relocation of car dismantling company Steenbergen (Case N 575/2005), summary notice in OJ C 80, 13.4.2007, p. 1.]. The Commission finally recalls that the CJEU, in its judgment in Lucchini, held that a national court was prevented from applying national law where the application of that law would have the effect of frustrating ‘the application of Community law in so far as it would make it impossible to recover State aid that was granted in breach of Community law’ [Case C-119/05 Lucchini, EU:C:2007:434, paragraph 59.]. The principle underlying this pronouncement is that a rule of national law cannot be applied where such application would frustrate the proper application of Union law [Ibid, paragraph 61.].
104 6. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 6.4. THE COMPENSATION AWARDED BY THE CONSIGLIO DI STATO DOES NOT CONSTITUTE DAMAGES, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1075
In forcesince 19 Jan 2015
Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 18 July 2007. Ministero dell'Industria, del Commercio e dell'Artigianato v Lucchini SpA.Decision
18 Jul 2007 · 62005CJ0119
Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 27 September 1988. Asteris AE and others v Hellenic Republic and European Economic Community.Decision
27 Sep 1988 · 61987CJ0106
Order of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 13 June 2006. Ornella Mancini v Commission of the European Communities.Decision
13 Jun 2006 · 62005CO0172
- case:eu=C-106/87
- case:eu=C-120/87