, Commission Decision of 04/07/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In forcesince 4 Jul 2012
81.

In assessing whether or not the remedies will restore effective competition, the Commission considers inter alia the type, scale and scope of the remedies by reference to the structure and the particular characteristics of the market in which these serious doubts arise. According to the European Union Courts' case law, commitments must be likely to eliminate competition concerns identified and ensure competitive market structures. In particular, contrary to those entered into during the phase II procedure, commitments offered in Phase I are intended not to prevent the creation or strengthening of a dominant position but rather to clearly dispel all serious doubts in that regard. The Commission enjoys a broad discretion in assessing whether these remedies constitute a direct and sufficient response capable of dispelling any such doubts. [36]

82.

The Commission has concluded that the Commitments, as submitted by the Parties on 25 June 2012 dispel all serious doubts identified in the course of the procedure.

83.

The divestiture of SPI France will lead to the elimination of any overlap between the Parties on the French market for standard outbound cross-border addressed mail delivery services offered to business customers.

84.

SPI France is an established competitor which will be sold as a going concern. The commitments, especially the access right to Swiss Post's network of multinational agreements, ascertain that SPI France will remain in a position to operate successfully on a sustainable basis. There will therefore be no discrimination between purchasers that are historic postal operators having access to international postal agreements and alternative operators which do not. The right to refer to the Divestment Business as the former business of SPI will further facilitate the establishment of the purchaser as a credible competitor in the French market for outbound cross-border business mail. [37]

85.

The commitments also ensure that the notified concentration will not strengthen the very strong position of the incumbent postal operator La Poste in a market that has been liberalised not so long ago and in which no entrants are to be expected in the medium term.

86.

For the reasons outlined above, the commitments entered into by the undertakings concerned are sufficient to eliminate the serious doubts as to the compatibility of the transaction with the internal market.

6.

Conditions and Obligations