Article 13 of Directive 97/67/EC [20] as amended by Directive 2002/39/EC [21] and Directive 2008/6/EC [22] (hereafter: the Postal Directive) provides that "terminal dues shall be fixed in relation to the costs of processing and delivering incoming cross-border mail, levels of remuneration shall be related to the quality of service achieved and terminal dues shall be transparent and non-discriminatory". As a result, La Poste cannot give preferential conditions to the JV. The tariffs for domestic mail distribution in France, on which terminal dues are based, are set under the supervision of the French postal regulator ARCEP, which is bound by the principles set out in the Postal Directive.
2.2.2. Incentive to Foreclose
Apart from the regulatory environment which serves as a strong containment to the ability of La Poste to foreclose there are also several reasons why La Poste would not have the incentive to foreclose.
First, La Poste's loss of revenues caused by giving preferential tariffs to the JV would have to be fully financed by La Poste, despite the fact that it will hold only 50% of the JV's shares. Any gains that the JV might realise as a result of such a preferential treatment would have to be shared with Swiss Post, the other shareholder of the JV.
Second, in a context of decreasing mail volumes and the use of Internet as an alternative to mail, La Poste has little to no incentive to risk losing any business by favouring the comparatively small activities of the JV in other Member States to the detriment of other postal operators in those countries. Postal operators outside France account for a substantial turnover of La Poste inbound revenue financing its distribution infrastructure in France. Terminal dues collected by La Poste from other UPU designated operators account, according to La Poste, for approximately […]% of its inbound mail revenues.
Lastly, La Poste's customers for inbound business mail in France are mainly large foreign postal operators. They are the operators on which La Poste relies in order to distribute its outgoing business mail from France in other countries and which are crucial for the distribution of La Poste's mail abroad. If La Poste were to discriminate against other postal operators in favour of the JV, these operators would retaliate by discriminating against La Poste in their inbound mail markets.
Conclusion