La Poste is the sole provider of inbound cross-border mail services in France, a market which is downstream of the market for outbound cross-border addressed mail services offered by La Poste or other postal operator to business customers in other Member States. The creation of the JV therefore leads to a vertically affected market in France.
The Parties argue that this vertical relationship should not raise serious doubts as to the compatibility of the JV with the internal market because La Poste will neither have (i) the ability nor (ii) the incentive to foreclose.
In the market investigation some competitors raised concerns as to La Poste's ability to foreclose the market following the implementation of the JV. However, these concerns were rather unsubstantiated and related more to La Poste's already dominant position on the French inbound mail market than to the impact of the JV. The Commission considers that foreclosure of the French inbound mail market is rather unlikely for the following reasons.
2.2.1. Ability to Foreclose
The conditions for the provision of most of the inbound mail distribution services in France are regulated (cross-border universal postal service). Conditions of service (including quality levels) are provided for in a detailed fashion by the "Reims" Agreements and, to a limited extent and notably for mail from third countries, within the framework of the Universal Postal Union (UPU).
As a UPU designated operator, La Poste is obliged to accept and deliver the cross-border mail it receives. Under the "Reims V" agreement, which La Poste signed on 20 December 2011, terminal dues paid for the delivery of inbound mail are a fixed percentage of the receiving operators' domestic tariffs, linked to the actually achieved quality of service. The "Reims V" agreement is open to any UPU designated operator that wishes to sign it, but the "Reims V" rates are also applied to non-designated postal operators which compete with "Reims" operators.