In light of these arguments, the Commission considers it unlikely that, following the creation of the JV, La Poste will have the ability and the incentive to foreclose access to its inbound mail services in France.
2.3. B2C cross-border standard parcel delivery services
As regards the Commission's practice [23] in defining the relevant markets of parcel delivery services, the Commission has previously made a distinction between:
domestic and cross-border delivery services;
express and standard delivery services; as well as
parcel delivery services to businesses and to consumers with a further possible sub-segmentation between business-to-business (B2B) parcel delivery services and business-to-consumers (B2C) parcel delivery services.
As to the geographic scope of the market, the Commission found it to be national.
The Parties agree with this view. Since the JV will only have small to moderate market shares with small increments in these markets, the Commission did not further investigate the issue of market definition in the market investigation.
Therefore, the national market for B2C cross-border standard parcel delivery services will be considered as one of the relevant markets for the purposes of the case at hand.
2.4. Cross-border standard parcel delivery services in Spain and the Netherlands
The concentration would lead to two other horizontally affected markets, namely the Spanish and Dutch markets of B2C cross-border standard parcel delivery services.
The Table below shows the position of the Parties on the respective markets:
Sales of B2C cross-border standard parcel delivery services (market shares 2011) |
Country |La Poste |Swiss Post |Joint Venture (i.e., share of Swiss Post which will be contributed to the JV) |
The Netherlands |[10-20]% |[0-5]% |[0-5]% |
Spain |[20-30]% |[0-5]% |[0-5]% |
Source: Form CO
Assessment
The Parties argue that the creation of the JV is unproblematic in this area as La Poste will not contribute its activities to the JV and the Swiss Post activities which will be contributed are minimal (reaching market shares of below [0-5]% in the Netherlands and below [0-5]% in Spain).