92 5. ASSESSMENT › 5.1. Evaluation of whether there is aid › 5.1.2. Selective advantage for an enterprise, Decision_act (EU) 2011/678

In forcesince 27 Jul 2011cited 3×

However, this argument cannot be accepted. As indicated in Decision N 9/05 and N 10/05, the selectivity criterion is met when the advantage is reserved for some enterprises or one sector. In this case, at national level, the financing of the BSE tests by the State only benefited one given sector, namely the sector involved in breeding animals subject to BSE tests. At Community level, the fact that the BSE tests were financed by the State or through State resources favoured Belgian enterprises and gave those enterprises an advantage over their foreign competitors for whom the mandatory BSE tests were not financed by the State or through State resources. In the preamble to the TSE guidelines (points 8 and 9), it was clearly indicated that the ongoing harmonisation obliging the sector to support the costs was slow, and that the Commission had thus decided to clarify and modify its policy on State aids with regard to the costs generated by the BSE tests. Point 24 of the TSE guidelines, for its part, indicates that the examination requirement could be based on Community or national legislation. This point clearly indicates that there is no Community harmonisation with regard to the obligation to perform the tests, which implies that this could also lead to an aid selectively benefiting the enterprises of a given Member State. In conclusion, the measures financed through State resources, including the contributions, give a selective advantage to farmers, slaughterhouses and other entities that process, handle, sell or trade in bovine animal products that are subject to compulsory BSE testing under the applicable legislation, by reducing the costs they must pay. These advantages are not conferred by direct payments, but by the public authorities covering the costs of the BSE tests by directly paying the laboratories which perform the tests on request from the slaughterhouses and invoice the costs to the FASFC.

  • Judgment of the General Court (First Chamber), 25 March 2015. Kingdom of Belgium v European Commission.Decision

    The Kingdom of Belgium claims that, at recitals 91 and 92 to the contested decision, the Commission found that there was a selective advantage, after stating that the measure at issue could lead to a distortion of competition in relation …

    25 Mar 2015 · 62011TJ0538

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 13 September 2017. European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium.Decision

    It asserts, secondly, that there is reasonable certainty that the de minimis thresholds were not exceeded, so that it did not fail in the slightest to fulfil the obligations flowing from the decision at issue. For this purpose, it contends …

    13 Sep 2017 · 62014CJ0591

  • Opinion of Advocate General Mengozzi delivered on 30 March 2017. European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium.Decision

    The classification in the decision at issue of the State financing of the BSE tests as aid is based on the idea that the effect of such financing is to reduce a burden that is normally borne by the budget of a given undertaking, conferring …

    30 Mar 2017 · 62014CC0591