First of all, Belgium indicated in its comments on the decision initiating the formal investigation procedure that it considered that the costs of the BSE tests were financed by the Member States because of their compulsory nature and that no Community rules required enterprises to bear the costs of controls. The agricultural guidelines for 2007-13 and the Commission’s practice clearly indicate that the different levels of test costs may distort competition, and that most States grant aid to cover the costs of these tests, whence the need the regulate its intensity in order to limit the distortions of competition caused by this aid. In particular, the TSE guidelines clearly state that the aid awarded by the States risks distorting competition. Point 24 of the TSE guidelines, for example, states that ‘from 1 January 2003, as far as compulsory BSE testing of bovine animals slaughtered for human consumption is concerned, direct and indirect State aid, including Community payments, may not be more than EUR 40 per test. The obligation for testing may be based on national or Community legislation.’ These guidelines were presented to the Member States, who were asked to take the appropriate measures and bring their schemes into line with these guidelines. Likewise, as far as the agricultural guidelines for 2007-13 are concerned, what qualifies as State aid with regard to the BSE tests is set out in points 132(f) and subsequent. Furthermore, it is important to emphasise that Decision N 9/05 and N 10/05, where a part of the financing of the BSE tests was classified as aid, was not the subject of an appeal by the Belgian authorities, which implicitly means that the Belgian authorities accepted this classification of the aid for financing BSE tests as State aid.
74 5. ASSESSMENT › 5.1. Evaluation of whether there is aid, Decision_act (EU) 2011/678
In forcesince 27 Jul 2011cited 1×
Opinion of Advocate General Mengozzi delivered on 30 March 2017. European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium.Decision
In the latter decision, the Commission distinguishes, inter alia, between financing of the ‘general random checks’, which ‘cannot be invoiced to an individual undertaking, as they are intended to ensure that the entire food chain is …
30 Mar 2017 · 62014CC0591