90 5. ASSESSMENT › 5.1. Evaluation of whether there is aid › 5.1.2. Selective advantage for an enterprise, Decision_act (EU) 2011/678

In forcesince 27 Jul 2011cited 2×

With regard to the measures financed through State resources, including the contributions, the Commission has constantly held the opinion [See in particular recital 73 of Decision N 9/05 and N 10/2005 which states that ‘the Commission has always considered that the financing by the State of the costs of the obligatory controls directly linked to production or to the placing on the market of a product constitutes a selective advantage benefiting those enterprises’.] that if the State finances the costs of the obligatory controls that concern the production or the marketing of products, this has to be considered as a selective advantage for the enterprises [See the TSE guidelines, e.g. points 7 and 12.]. Indeed, the State reduced the charges that are normally included in the budget of an enterprise. It can be deduced from the above that the farmers, the slaughterhouses and other entities which process, handle, sell or market products from bovine animals for whom BSE tests are obligatory by virtue of the legislation in force during the period in question, are conducting an economic activity and have benefited from State aid for the financing of the BSE tests by the State, and this since 1 January 2001.

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 13 September 2017. European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium.Decision

    As regards the Kingdom of Belgium’s argument that the decision at issue is non-existent, put forward in the event that the aid at issue should be recovered exclusively from farmers, it is to be noted that, both in recitals 90, 92 and 99 …

    13 Sep 2017 · 62014CJ0591

  • Opinion of Advocate General Mengozzi delivered on 30 March 2017. European Commission v Kingdom of Belgium.Decision

    The classification in the decision at issue of the State financing of the BSE tests as aid is based on the idea that the effect of such financing is to reduce a burden that is normally borne by the budget of a given undertaking, conferring …

    30 Mar 2017 · 62014CC0591