Art. 9 Decision_act (EU) 2008/909

Grounds for non-recognition and non-enforcement

In forcesince 28 Mar 2009cited 25×
1.

The competent authority of the executing State may refuse to recognise the judgment and enforce the sentence, if:

(a)

the certificate referred to in Article 4 is incomplete or manifestly does not correspond to the judgment and has not been completed or corrected within a reasonable deadline set by the competent authority of the executing State;

(b)

the criteria set forth in Article 4(1) are not met;

(c)

enforcement of the sentence would be contrary to the principle of ne bis in idem;

(d)

in a case referred to in Article 7(3) and, where the executing State has made a declaration under Article 7(4), in a case referred to in Article 7(1), the judgment relates to acts which would not constitute an offence under the law of the executing State. However, in relation to taxes or duties, customs and exchange, execution of a judgment may not be refused on the ground that the law of the executing State does not impose the same kind of tax or duty or does not contain the same type of rules as regards taxes, duties and customs and exchange regulations as the law of the issuing State;

(e)

the enforcement of the sentence is statute-barred according to the law of the executing State;

(f)

there is immunity under the law of the executing State, which makes it impossible to enforce the sentence;

(g)

the sentence has been imposed on a person who, under the law of the executing State, owing to his or her age, could not have been held criminally liable for the acts in respect of which the judgment was issued;

(h)

at the time the judgment was received by the competent authority of the executing State, less than six months of the sentence remain to be served;

(i)

according to the certificate provided for in Article 4, the person did not appear in person at the trial resulting in the decision, unless the certificate states that the person, in accordance with further procedural requirements defined in the national law of the issuing State:

(i)

in due time:

either was summoned in person and thereby informed of the scheduled date and place of the trial which resulted in the decision, or by other means actually received official information of the scheduled date and place of that trial in such a manner that it was unequivocally established that he or she was aware of the scheduled trial,

and

was informed that a decision may be handed down if he or she does not appear for the trial;

or

(ii)

being aware of the scheduled trial had given a mandate to a legal counsellor, who was either appointed by the person concerned or by the State, to defend him or her at the trial, and was indeed defended by that counsellor at the trial;

or

(iii)

after being served with the decision and being expressly informed of the right to a retrial, or an appeal, in which the person has the right to participate and which allows the merits of the case, including fresh evidence, to be re-examined, and which may lead to the original decision being reversed:

expressly stated that he or she does not contest the decision,

or

did not request a retrial or appeal within the applicable time frame;

(j)

the executing State, before a decision is taken in accordance with Article 12(1), makes a request, in accordance with Article 18(3), and the issuing State does not consent, in accordance with Article 18(2)(g), to the person concerned being prosecuted, sentenced or otherwise deprived of his or her liberty in the executing State for an offence committed prior to the transfer other than that for which the person was transferred;

(k)

the sentence imposed includes a measure of psychiatric or health care or another measure involving deprivation of liberty, which, notwithstanding Article 8(3), cannot be executed by the executing State in accordance with its legal or health care system;

(l)

the judgment relates to criminal offences which under the law of the executing State are regarded as having been committed wholly or for a major or essential part within its territory, or in a place equivalent to its territory.

2.

Any decision under paragraph 1(l) in relation to offences committed partly within the territory of the executing State, or in a place equivalent to its territory, shall be taken by the competent authority of the executing State in exceptional circumstances and on a case-by-case basis, having regard to the specific circumstances of the case, and in particular to whether a major or essential part of the conduct in question has taken place in the issuing State.

3.

In the cases referred to in paragraph 1(a), (b), (c), (i), (k) and (l), before deciding not to recognise the judgment and enforce the sentence, the competent authority of the executing State shall consult the competent authority of the issuing State, by any appropriate means, and shall, where appropriate, ask it to supply any necessary additional information without delay.

The 10 that are cited most themselves, of 25.

  • Decision_act (EU) 2009/2991Law

    … на член 8, параграф 2, буква д) от Рамково решение 2006/783/ПВР, на член 9, параграф 1, буква и) от Рамково решение 2008/909/ПВР и на член 11, …

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 11 January 2017. Criminal proceedings against Jozef Grundza.Decisioninterprets

    This request for a preliminary ruling concerns the interpretation of Articles 7(3) and 9(1)(d) of Council Framework Decision 2008/909/JHA of 27 November 2008 on the application of the principle of mutual recognition to judgments in …

    11 Jan 2017 · 62015CJ0289

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 9 November 2023. Staatsanwaltschaft Aachen v M.D.Decision

    For that purpose, Article 8 of Framework Decision 2008/909 provides that the executing authority is, in principle, required to grant the request seeking recognition of a judgment and enforcement of a custodial sentence or measure involving …

    9 Nov 2023 · 62021CJ0819

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 November 2016. Criminal proceedings against Ognyanov.Decision

    As stated by the Advocate General in point 100 of his Opinion, Articles 4 to 14 of Framework Decision 2008/909 begin by establishing the rules which the Member States must follow in order to effect the transfer of a sentenced person. …

    8 Nov 2016 · 62014CJ0554

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 28 July 2016. Criminal proceedings against Jozef Grundza.Decision

    In these circumstances Krajský súd v Prešove (Regional Court, Prešov) stayed proceedings and referred the following question to the Court of Justice: ‘On a proper interpretation of Articles 7(3) and 9(1)(d) of Framework Decision …

    28 Jul 2016 · 62015CC0289

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bot delivered on 3 May 2016. Criminal proceedings against Ognyanov.Decision

    As regards the first phase, Articles 4 to 14 of the Framework Decision lay down the rules which the Member States must follow in order to effect the transfer of a sentenced person. More specifically, Articles 4 to 6 define the procedures …

    3 May 2016 · 62014CC0554

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bot delivered on 15 February 2017. Daniel Adam Popławski.Decision

    If the domestic law transposes the regime introduced by Framework Decision 2008/909, the refusal to surrender presupposes that all of the conditions laid down in that framework decision are satisfied in such a way as to enable the sentence …

    15 Feb 2017 · 62015CC0579

  • Opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour delivered on 18 September 2025. Staatsanwaltschaft Berlin.Decision

    That functional link, which ensures that the system of procedural safeguards enjoyed by persons convicted in absentia is consistent and clear, leads me to consider, in the context of the implementation of Framework Decision 2008/909, that, …

    18 Sep 2025 · 62024CC0447

  • Opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour delivered on 18 September 2025. ATAU v Procura generale presso la Corte d’appello di Napoli.Decision

    … that his sentence be served in the executing Member State does not, as such, meet the conditions laid down in Article 9(1)(i)(iii) of Framework Decision 2008/909. Admittedly, ATAU’s attitude may seem contradictory in so far as, in …

    18 Sep 2025 · 62024CC0095

  • Opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour delivered on 12 December 2024. C.J.Decision

    … основанията за отказ за признаване и изпълнение, предвидени в член 9 от Рамково решение 2008/909, според мен това по никакъв начин не …

    13 Jun 2024 · 62022CC0305