70 6. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › 6.1. Classification as State aid: existence of an advantage › 6.1.3. Analysis of the existence of a reduction in financial charges for TVO, Decision_act (EU) 2008/281

In forcesince 25 Sep 2007

EREF disputes the assertion that the interest rate for the credit facility is a sound estimate of the market rate that would have been charged by the banks in the absence of a public guarantee. Firstly, it takes the view that BLB's role regarding the credit facility constitutes aid and favourably influenced the conditions on which it was granted to TVO. The Commission notes that, in its decision in Case NN 62/B/06 [EREF brought before the Court of First Instance an appeal against Commission final decision C(2006) 4963 concerning Case NN 62/B/06. The Court registered the appeal under No T-94/07.], it ruled out the possibility that BLB's role might constitute aid. It therefore rejects the complainant's first assertion. Secondly, EREF considers that the Coface guarantee reduced the risk attaching to the credit facility and thus encouraged the banks to grant the latter on more favourable conditions than a loan not backed by a public guarantee. On this point, la Commission notes that EREF does not indicate the precise mechanism by which the Coface guarantee would reduce the risk attaching to the credit facility. It has analysed in detail the financing of the Olkiluoto 3 project. Although the Coface guarantee clearly reduces the risk attaching to the loan as regards the banks that provided it and therefore lowers the interest rate charged by them for the guaranteed loan, the Commission has not identified any mechanism or contract whereby the Coface guarantee would lower the risk attaching to the credit facility. It should be pointed out that the Coface guarantee in no way covers the credit facility. Accordingly, the Commission rejects the complainant's assertion that the Coface guarantee reduces the risk attaching to the credit facility.

  • Order of the Court of First Instance (Sixth Chamber) of 19 November 2009. European Renewable Energies Federation ASBL (EREF) v Commission ofDecision

    19 Nov 2009 · 62007TO0094