As for the assessment of the measure in question, the French authorities argue mainly that the measure cannot be classified as aid. They maintain in particular that it does not confer any advantage. According to them, the Coface guarantee was granted on market terms. They comment on the methodology applied by the Commission in its decision to initiate the procedure. They regard it as one commonly used by banks and note that it shows that the guarantee premium was granted at market rates. They go on to say that the methodology can be usefully supplemented and verified by applying a more complex method for valuing financial assets which they describe as a ‘method for comparing credit values’. On the basis of this second method, the French authorities come to the conclusion that a bank would have attributed a higher value to the guaranteed loan than to the credit facility, that is to say, they would have regarded the former as being more remunerative. This amounts to saying that the credit guaranteed by Coface confers no advantage on any of the partners in the project in the form of lower financing costs. The French authorities also argue that the measure cannot be classified as Sstate aid since it affects neither competition nor trade between Member States.
55 5. COMMENTS BY FRANCE, Decision_act (EU) 2008/281
In forcesince 25 Sep 2007