In its decision of 24 October 2006, the Commission examined for the first time whether the measure constituted aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty. The decision ascertained in detail whether or not an advantage was conferred. The Commission noted that the insurance premium of [2,5-3,5]% charged by Coface could not be compared directly to a market rate since no insurer seemed to offer this type of financial product. However, as the public guarantee was for a loan, it seemed that the total cost of the guaranteed loan — defined as the sum of the interest paid and the guarantee premium — could be compared with that which would have had to be borne by the borrower if there had been no public guarantee. On the basis of a comparison of the total cost of the guaranteed loan with the cost of the credit facility described in Section 2.2.1, the latter being regarded as a market rate, the Commission came to the preliminary conclusion that the guaranteed loan did not seem to reduce the financial charges that the borrower would normally have had to bear. It would seem, therefore, that no advantage was conferred on TVO. The Commission would though point out that this preliminary conclusion is based on a certain number of assumptions. And so it was unable to rule out at that stage any possibility that the measure constituted aid and it decided to allow France and the interested parties to comment on the methodology used and on the assumptions on which the Commission based its analysis of the existence of an advantage.
45 3. GROUNDS FOR INITIATING THE PROCEDURE, Decision_act (EU) 2008/281
In forcesince 25 Sep 2007