53 4. COMMENTS BY INTERESTED PARTIES, Decision_act (EU) 2008/281

In forcesince 25 Sep 2007

In addition to the three letters mentioned in paragraphs 48, 49 and 50, the Commission received comments from six Member States — the Netherlands, Sweden, Finland, the Czech Republic, Austria and Germany — and from the Chairman of the Council Export Credits Group [Germany, which is chairing the Group, has pointed out that the United Kingdom does not agree with all of the views expressed.]. The Member States concerned do not comment on the specific features of the case but criticise the Commission for initiating the Article 88(2) procedure in respect of an export credit and for taking the view that such a measure may constitute incompatible State aid. They consider that export credits are governed by the OECD Arrangement, which has been incorporated into Community law. By subjecting an export credit to the state aid procedures laid down in Article 88 of the EC Treaty, the Commission is creating considerable legal uncertainty and may be weakening the position of European exporters vis-à-vis their foreign competitors.