72 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › V.1. State Aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty › Distortion of competition › Different level of public support to commercial broadcasters, Decision_act (EU) 2006/513

In forcesince 9 Nov 2005

The differences in Mabb's subsidy to the respective CSBs distort competition since these broadcasters compete on the same relevant market for free-to-air television broadcasting. The Commission has consistently found that the provision of pay-TV constitutes a market separate from free-to-air television broadcasting [More recent decisions are, for example, Telenor/Canal+/Canal Digital (COMP/C.2/38.287, 29 December 2003), Newscorp/Telepiù (COMP/M.2876, 2 April 2003), BSkyB/Kirch Pay TV (COMP/JV.37, 21 March 2000), Telefonica Endemol (COMP/M.1943, 11 July 2000) and TPS II (COMP/JV.57, 30 April 2002).]. The markets are separate in particular with respect to the type of trading relationship which exists between the broadcaster and the revenue provider (e.g. subscriber or advertiser) as well as with respect to the form of funding, with pay-TV being financed primarily by subscription fees while free-to-air television is financed by public authorities and/or by advertising revenue [European Commission, DG Competition, Market Definition in the Media Sector — Comparative Legal Analysis, Volume I, December 2002, p. 73.]. In the case at hand, the recipients of Mabb's subsidy compete more specifically with each other for advertising or other commercial revenue since they are commercially funded [This is also true for BBC World, which describes itself explicitly as commercially funded.].