67 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › V.1. State Aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty › Distortion of competition › Award of network licences and broadcasting licences, Decision_act (EU) 2006/513

In forcesince 9 Nov 2005

In the case of the remaining transmission capacity for CSBs, Mabb published a first tender on 8 May 2002 and a second tender on 16 April 2004 [See paragraphs 16-17.]. Although the attribution of licences via a tender is generally preferable to the direct attribution, the Commission considers for the following reasons that the tender procedures in the present case cannot be considered to have minimised or even eliminated the economic advantage of Mabb's funding and were thus inadequate to prevent a distortion of competition. Neither of the two tenders gave a binding commitment that Mabb would subsidise the transmission costs. The first tender stated explicitly that the funding would depend on a number of conditions related to the network roll-out. Moreover, the tenders did not give an indication of the possible amount of any funding. The respective tender specifications mentioned only that the annual transmission costs per programme channel were likely to vary between EUR 150000 and EUR 200000. The Commission therefore considers that the two tender procedures were not sufficiently transparent to ensure that the advantage deriving from Mabb's subsidy would be adequately reflected in broadcasters’ bids or to exclude any degree of selectivity [In a fully transparent and open tender procedure, the bidding broadcasters could be expected to transfer part or all of the advantage deriving from a subsidy into higher or qualitatively better bids for the licence.].