42 IV. COMMENTS FROM THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY, Decision_act (EU) 2006/513

In forcesince 9 Nov 2005

In its response to the decision to initiate the procedure, Germany takes the view that the assistance granted by Mabb does not constitute aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty. Firstly, the assistance did not come from State resources since the funds were not under State control, and Mabb was free to decide how they were to be used. Secondly, the assistance was not granted to specific beneficiaries. This was the case not only with the commercial broadcasters as direct beneficiaries but also with the network operator as indirect beneficiary, since the assistance granted to the undertakings concerned was the result of open and transparent tender procedures. As a result, no specific undertaking benefited. Thirdly, Germany states that the assistance did not distort competition. In the case of the broadcasters, the digital switch-over increased competition since capacities for additional programme channels became available. In the case of the network operator, the various modes of transmission were not sufficiently substitutable, this being a necessary condition for a distortion of competition.