69 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › V.1. State Aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty › Distortion of competition › Award of network licences and broadcasting licences, Decision_act (EU) 2006/513

In forcesince 9 Nov 2005

The tender procedures at network level were thus characterised by a high degree of uncertainty and intransparency coupled with a strong position of the incumbent terrestrial network operator T-Systems. These elements made it difficult for any company other than the incumbent operator of the terrestrial network, T-Systems, to submit a bid for the operation of the network. Indeed, T-Systems was the only company which submitted a bid for the operation of the relevant multiplexes. In its response to the decision to initiate the procedure, Germany has recognised that the network level is characterised by conditions which are not fully market-driven. Reference is made to the strong position of the network operator T-Systems as the successor to the previous telecommunications monopoly [Reply of Germany of 24 September 2004, point 1.3.2, p. 32 (‘Der Umstieg hätte voraussichtlich […] ohne jede finanzielle Förderung realisiert werden können, wenn im Bereich der Organisation des Sendernetzbetriebes voll marktkonforme Bedingungen bestanden hätten.’) (‘T-Systems als Nachfolger des früheren Fernmeldemonopols’).]. As T-Systems was in a favourable position to operate the DVB-T network, it may have submitted an offer that did not fully correspond to the economic advantage derived from the operation of the network. The tender procedures must be therefore considered insufficient to exclude the selectivity of the measure and thus insufficient to prevent a distortion of competition.