104 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › V.2. Compatibility assessment › Article 87(3)(c) of the EC Treaty › Positive externalities, Decision_act (EU) 2006/513

In forcesince 9 Nov 2005

Germany has argued that the subsidy is needed to free up the spectrum by compensating CSBs for giving up their ATT licences. As explained in more detail in paragraphs 57-61 [See paragraphs 57-61.], there are, however, a number of reasons which contradict this line of argument. To sum up, the reasons are that Mabb could have limited the ATT licence to the switch-over date; the CSBs present in ATT had already been compensated by the award of DVB-T licences and the subsidy is not conceived or calculated as a compensation payment.