Recital 87, Decision_act (EU) 2004/340

In forcesince 5 Nov 2003

The refundable and non-refundable subsidies received by González y Díez S.A. in the context of the SPCA Agreement signed on 30 December 1989 with the Ministry of Industry and Energy, were intended to finance projects whose purpose is to promote coal production under economically viable conditions and to increase productivity. The loans were received during the period 1990 to 1993 when the projects were implemented. According to what can be deduced from Annex III of the agreement signed, the refundable loan of 313500000 pesetas was mainly intended for the establishment of the new system of operation by "soutirage", which was and continues to be used by the company according to the report by independent experts, Annex III of the SPCA Agreement also refers to " clear indications of exceptional open-cast operations, which would enhance the estimated profitability of the whole" and of an annual production target of 260000 marketable tonnes, which was exceeded. The payment of 233492186 pesetas (EUR 1403316) in the years 1999 and 2000, however, corresponds to the repayment of loans received between 1990 and 1993, and is unrelated to the company's activity reduction plan notified to the Commission for the period 1998 to 2001. The Commission also points out that the payments made by the company in 1999 and 2000 are much higher than envisaged in the initial plan owing to the payment delays, as emerges from the letter of the Ministry of Industry and Energy (MINER) sent by registered post on 22 December 1997 and other documentation sent to the Commission. The Commission also points out that the refundable loan of 313500000 pesetas was accompanied by a non-refundable subsidy of 209 million pesetas and by another non-refundable subsidy of 23 million pesetas for research and technological development activities. In addition to these capital subsidies, the company received each year aid to cover approximately 40 % of the underground operation production costs and 27 % of the open-cast operation production costs. As explained earlier, the Commission proposes to authorise the entire residual value on 31 December 2000 of the fixed assets in the La Prohida subsector and in a substantial part of the Buseiro sector. The aid amounting to 233492186 pesetas (181292186 pesetas in 1998 and 52200000 pesetas in 2000) corresponding to the repayment of SPCA subsidies, which could include investments in mine works in the La Prohida subsector, would result in an accumulation of aid incompatible with the common market. Accordingly, the Commission cannot authorise that aid.