After analysing the "Project for the open-cast working of the Buseiro zone" dated July 1994, submitted as an Annex in the document from Uría & Menéndez, the Commission noted that the Buseiro deposit shows numerous geological irregularities and therefore uncertainties in its future operation. The descriptions given by the independent mining experts of Layer I are partial, given that they correspond only to the southern part of the deposit. The Project mentions the complexity of the western side. As regards the real presence of Layer I, it indicates that this level cannot be worked in some places because of the high ash content, justifies the choice of variant 5 for the determination of reserve volumes and suggests an alternative to arrive at the figure of 450000 tonnes. The Commission does not agree with the comments by González y Díez S.A. concerning the effect on the additional costs incurred in the Buseiro Group by the technical modifications of that project, and on the contrary accepts the view of the independent experts that the additional costs resulting from the reduction of production are those due to the overburden excavation of 1005080 m3 in the northern zone. The Commission also considers that the said movement of 1005080 m3 of excavation residues was overestimated, since although the independent experts were unable to evaluate that figure, the experts who proposed the report of January 2001 cite "the experience obtained by the partial working of the bottom of the syncline in the northern zone (the only one in which the bottom was reached) where the coal ash in that vein (the wall vein) ranges between 40 % and 60 %". After analysing the technical studies, the Commission concludes that the only expenditure attributable to activity reduction in the Buseiro sector is that corresponding to the overburden excavation in the northern zone, with its corresponding associated restoration costs in the external mine waste tip. The Commission also considers that the change of plan was due to geological factors already taken into account in the original project and that the extra costs due to those geological factors should in no case be covered by additional aid, since the company has received operational aid every year.
Recital 80, Decision_act (EU) 2004/340
In forcesince 5 Nov 2003