Recital 40, Decision_act (EU) 2004/340

In forcesince 5 Nov 2003

From a legal point of view, in its communication dated 26 May 2003 the company González y Díez S.A. considers that the Commission does not have the competence to give a ruling. Neither the ECSC Treaty, nor the EC Treaty, nor the Nice Protocol on the financial consequences of the expiry of the ECSC Treaty and the Coal and Steel Research Fund confer such competence upon it. The Commission does not indicate what legal instrument allows it to initiate and determine proceedings on coal aid agreed upon before the expiry of the ECSC Treaty, which occurred on 23 July 2002. The EC Treaty does not empower the Commission to examine aid for coal mining granted by the Member States earlier than 24 July 2002. The general principles of non-retroactivity of legal rules and legitimate expectations go against the application of legal rules to situations that precede their entry into force. No text establishes the possibility of the retroactive application of the EC Treaty to situations earlier than 24 July 2002 and, in particular, to aid for coal mining agreed upon before that date. Consequently, the Commission was not authorised to initiate and decide the said proceedings.