Recital 352, Decision_act (EU) 2003/674

In forcesince 2 Jul 2002

In its request for information, the Commission sought mainly to obtain factual clarification of documents (and certain unclear quotations made in those documents) found at Degussa's premises during the investigation carried out on 16 June 1999 and the production of documents already in existence. It is settled case-law of the Courts(114) that the Commission is entitled to request such factual clarification. In this respect, the Court of First Instance stated(115) that "the mere fact of being obliged to answer purely factual questions put by the Commission [...] cannot constitute a breach of the principle of respect for the rights of defence or impair the right to fair legal process. There is nothing to prevent the addressee of such questions or requests from showing, whether later during the administrative procedure or in proceedings before the Community courts, when exercising his rights of defence, that the facts set out in his replies or the documents produced by him have a different meaning from that ascribed to them by the Commission."