The Commission cannot accept this argument and reaffirms its view that most of Degussa's cooperation can not be classified as "voluntary". Indeed, most of the information provided by Degussa in reply to the Article 11 request falls entirely within the ambit of an undertaking's duty under Article 11 of Regulation No 17 to reply fully to such requests. None of the questions in the Commission's Article 11 letter referred to by Degussa in support of its claim can be considered as undermining Degussa's rights of defence. As the Court held in the Orkem case(113), Regulation No 17 does not give an undertaking under investigation any right to evade the investigation on the grounds that the results thereof might provide evidence of an infringement by it of the competition rules. On the contrary, it imposes on the undertaking an obligation to cooperate actively, which implies that it must make available to the Commission all information relating to the subject-matter of the investigation.
Recital 351, Decision_act (EU) 2003/674
In forcesince 2 Jul 2002