The Commission rejects this approach. Firstly, it is demonstrated (see recitals 276 to 291) that the infringement had an impact on the EEA methionine market. Secondly, the fact that the cartel did not achieve all the results desired by its members in no way proves that the cartel had no effect on the market. It is clear that price-fixing and market-sharing cartels by nature jeopardise the proper functioning of the single market. What matters is that the normal competitive pattern that would have governed the single market for methionine was replaced by a system of collusion concerning the price of the product, the essential component of competition. As such, the infringement of Article 81(1) EC and 53(1) EEA is considered to be very serious.
The actual impact of the infringement on the methionine market in the EEA