Recital 274, Decision_act (EU) 2003/674

In forcesince 2 Jul 2002

Nippon Soda argues that the Commission has not sufficiently demonstrated the real gravity of the infringement in assessing the nature of the infringement (and for the purpose of the assessment of any fine), although it does not contest that the infringement of Article 81(1) EC and Article 53(1) EEA is established. In this respect, Nippon Soda submits that the cartel not only lacked the ability (and in particular the demonstrated ability) to exert any meaningful influence on the European market but was singularly ineffective. In Nippon Soda's view, the Commission's documents show that those attending the meetings had little or no ability to control the market in the manner one would expect of an effective cartel.