As regards invoking the nature or general scheme of the tax system as a possible justification for the exemption from corporation tax, the Commission emphasises that what matters is to know whether the tax measures involved meet the objectives inherent in the tax system itself, or whether, on the contrary, they pursue other, possibly legitimate objectives outside the tax system. Furthermore, it is up to the Member State concerned to establish that the tax measures in question follow the internal logic of the tax system(45). In this particular case, the General Assembly of Vizcaya states that, basically, because it promotes the formation of new companies the tax exemption will mean an increase in the number of taxpayers and hence in tax revenue. However, to support this thesis, it has contented itself with a set of abstract, general statements without providing a detailed study of how, in this specific case, the loss of revenue resulting from the 10-year exemption would be balanced by the possible subsequent increase in revenue. In the absence of a detailed analysis it is risky to assume that the balance will always be positive. Moreover, the General Assembly of Vizcaya does not explain why, if the objective was to increase the number of taxpayers, the aid is only granted to a minimum number of new firms, perhaps less than 5 %. Apart from this, the measure's temporary nature shows that its objectives, rather than being intrinsic to the tax system, which would give them a certain permanence, are short-term and unconnected with it. In the circumstances, the Commission must reject the comments of the General Assembly of Vizcaya, since the latter has not managed to show that the tax exemption has the objective, inherent in the tax system, of increasing tax revenue. The Commission notes however that, according to the provincial law introducing the tax holiday, the declared objective was to stimulate Vizcaya's economy, which was then in serious crisis. The objective is not determined therefore by primary tax concerns, but by economic policy considerations unconnected with the tax system. This extraneous quality is reinforced by the temporary nature of the tax measure. As regards the possibly legitimate nature of the objectives pursued, the Commission does not question this, although it would point out that it is not sufficient for a public measure to avoid being examined from a State aid perspective, since, as the case-law states(46): "If that argument were followed, it would be sufficient for the public authorities to invoke the legitimacy of the objectives which the adoption of an aid measure sought to attain for that measure to be regarded as a general measure outside the scope of Article 92(1) of the Treaty. That provision does not distinguish between measures of State intervention by reference to their causes or aims but defines them in relation to their effects".
Recital 70, Decision_act (EU) 2003/86
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001