As regards invoking the nature or general scheme of the tax system as a possible justification for the measure's compatibility, the General Assembly of Vizcaya questions the Commission's view that the objective of promoting the formation of new companies is unconnected with the tax system. Not only is promoting the formation of viable new companies an objective recognised by the Treaty, but it creates new taxpayers for the tax system. However, increasing the number of taxpayers is a primary, intrinsic objective of the tax system. For instance, the purpose and effect of reducing indirect taxes such as VAT is to expose the black economy in order to incorporate it within the tax system. As for direct taxation, the purpose of cutting high marginal rates of, for example, income tax is to reduce their disincentive effect, promote economic activity and hence increase tax revenue. In this particular case, the General Assembly of Vizcaya also states that because the tax exemption is aimed at the formation of new companies, it promotes the creation of new taxpayers. Thus, since the measure will make it possible to form new companies, tax revenue will increase, thereby fulfilling the basic objective of any tax system.
Recital 56, Decision_act (EU) 2003/86
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001