Recital 71, Decision_act (EU) 2003/86

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

As to the existence of exemptions from corporation tax in other Member States and the fact that the Commission did not regard them as State aid because they were aimed at new firms - a point that, according to certain third parties, gives rise to legitimate expectations concerning tax aid for newly established firms - the Commission would point out that the preliminary results of the investigation of this question cast doubt on this line of argument. The tax holidays of these Member States were deemed to be State aid schemes(47) notified under Article 88(3) of the Treaty and compatible with the common market. Furthermore, even supposing that the Commission had not reacted, it would not be legitimate to take this misguided approach in the present case. It should be pointed out that, according to the case-law of the Court of Justice, "any breach by a Member State of an obligation under the Treaty in connection with the prohibition laid down in Article 92 cannot be justified by the fact that other Member States are also failing to fulfil this obligation. The effects of more than one distortion of competition on trade between Member States do not cancel one another out but accumulate and the damaging consequences to the common market are increased"(48).