Recital 47, Decision_act (EU) 2003/86

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

According to Confebask, since a legitimate expectation has been aroused, in particular by the letter of 22 May 1994, reference 4555, which the Commission sent to the Spanish Permanent Representation in order to obtain information, the measure cannot be the subject of a recovery. The letter shows, firstly, that the Commission learned of the measure back in 1994 and, secondly, that the complainant described it as State aid. The Commission, however, did not initiate the procedure but apparently agreed with the reply from the Spanish authorities, who denied that the measure was State aid. The situation described recalls the earlier one examined by the Court of Justice in RSV(24). In that case, the Court held that the period of 26 months between the decision to initiate the procedure and the final decision had established on the part of the beneficiary a legitimate expectation of such a nature as to prevent the Commission from ordering the Dutch authorities to order the refund of the aid. Confebask considers that, if a period of 26 months between the initiation of the procedure and its conclusion establishes a legitimate expectation which prevents the recovery of the aid being ordered, a situation in which the Commission does not even initiate the procedure for six years and six months, so that no position is adopted concerning the possible existence of aid that is incompatible with the common market, is even clearer still. In short, the undertakings and authorities informed of the questions raised by the Commission, which did not react to the reply provided by the Spanish authorities, would be entitled to think that the system of exemption from corporation tax gave no cause for complaint as far as the State aid rules were concerned. Confebask also mentions other factors that prevented an experienced economic operator from noticing any irregularity in its acceptance of the tax concession in question. As early as 1993, the common tax law (i.e. the legislation applicable in the rest of Spain) contained systems for exempting newly established firms from corporation tax. Basically, these systems are no different from those in the Basque legislation cited in these pleadings. In the circumstances, no recipient firm could foresee that several years after being informed of these rules, which are similar to those applicable in the rest of the common territory, the Commission, relying on Community law, would demand the recovery of the aid. As already explained, such recovery would involve recalculating the tax debt for tax periods that were closed years ago, which would be a manifest assault on legal certainty.