The Commission also considers that the tax exemption does not satisfy the conditions in Article 1(b)(v)(50). Neither in its correspondence nor in any other document has the Commission ever stated directly or indirectly that it considers the tax measure in question is not aid. On the contrary, in Decision 98/C 103/03 of 18 November 1997(51), it took the view that the new tax holiday that Álava introduced in 1996, and for which, in addition to other aid, Demesa was eligible, could contain aid elements that might be incompatible. Subsequently, in Decision 1999/718/EC concluding the procedure, the Commission considered that the 1996 tax holiday was State aid that was incompatible with the common market. The Commission has followed the same approach of considering tax holidays as State aid with regard to other tax measures introduced by other Member States, such as France (decision of 21 January 1987 in Case N 155/86 and of 29 November 1995 in Case N 493/95), Italy (decision of 2 March 1988) and Luxembourg (decision of 9 December 1992 in Case N 607/92 and of 20 September in Case N 72/96). Since all these decisions, except 1999/718/EC, were adopted not only before 10 December 1998 (date of publication of the Commission notice on the application of the State aid rules to measures relating to direct business taxation) but even before 1 December 1997 (date of the resolution on a code of conduct for business taxation), the Commission would emphasise that the decision to consider the tax holiday introduced in 1993 as State aid is not due, as the Vizcaya Provincial Council claims in its comments, to the Commission changing the criterion when examining current tax schemes in the light of the notice or of the code of conduct.
Recital 76, Decision_act (EU) 2003/86
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001
- celex=31972D0096
- num:eu=1997/718