The audit reveals shortcomings in the checks on the invoices submitted by the property developer (supporting documents for certain additional work, allowances made for less costly work/materials than originally estimated). In view of the amounts involved (just over ECU 2,5 million) and the risk that the Communities will continue to have to bear them, the Court of Justice should institute additional inquiries.
Rent for the Palais
Contrary to a commitment, made in 1984 within the framework of the negotiations concerning the building of the annexes, to reduce the rent for the main building, the Palais, by an amount equivalent to the repayment of loans on this building, in 1994 payment in full of the sums due under the initial rental agreement continued to be demanded, even though the Palais had by then been paid off. The Court of Justice then decided to suspend payment of this rent as from 1995. Subsequently, in 1996, the Court of Justice agreed to resume paying this rent as from 1997. The Court of Justice's motive at the time went beyond the mere obligation to fulfil its contractual commitments and had more to do with its assessment of what was acceptable in budgetary terms in respect of the total amount of rents demanded than with an evaluation of their justification. Such an attitude, which results in the Communities having to bear financial costs according to the amount of appropriations entered in their budget, is not in itself indicative of sound financial management.
Conclusion
The Court of Justice undertook a major property-development programme in order gradually to extend the premises it occupies on the Kirchberg plateau under circumstances which call for the following comments:
implementation of the programme was entrusted to the Luxembourg administration without adequate information having been passed on beforehand to the Budgetary Authority and without the financial, administrative and technical conditions for its implementation having been laid down in a contract between the parties concerned;
the implementation of this programme was in turn subcontracted to a property developer within the framework of legal and financial arrangements which have proved costly;
the arrangements accepted by the Court of Justice, the user of the buildings, made it virtually impossible to monitor the implementation and to control the costs;