Special Report No 5/2000
on the Court of Justice's expenditure on buildings (annexe buildings Erasmus, Thomas More and Annexe C), together with the Court of Justice's replies
(pursuant to Article 248(4), second subparagraph, of the EC Treaty)
(2000/C 109/01)
CONTENTS
>TABLE>
Introduction
On 15 November 1994, the Court of Justice of the European Communities concluded a rental agreement with the Luxembourg administration with a view to buying(1) three buildings annexed to the main building, the "Palais", situated on the Kirchberg plateau, which this institution has occupied since 1972.
Between 1986 and 1994, the Luxembourg administration arranged for the construction(2) of these three buildings (see photo below), covering a total surface area of 65949 m2, in accordance with the Court of Justice's specific requirements(3). These constructions have gradually been added on to each other in response to the Court of Justice's constantly developing needs and, since completion of the work in 1994, one single building complex has thus been able to accommodate all the Court of Justice's staff, which had previously been dispersed over a number of sites. The expenditure relating to this construction programme (Annexe A or "Erasmus", Annexe B or "Thomas More" and Annexe C) amounted in total to LUF 9200 million (i.e. about ECU 200 million, excluding VAT) (see Table 1). This expenditure was the subject of a Court of Auditors' audit which focused on the construction of these three annexe buildings, the conclusion of the Agreement of 15 November 1994 and its implementation up until 1998.
>PIC FILE= "C_2000109EN.000201.EPS">
Table 1
Construction cost
>TABLE>
Launch of the construction programme
By 1979, the Court of Justice's workload and staff had expanded to such an extent that it was obliged to rent office accommodation outside its main building. From the early 1980s onwards, it entrusted the Luxembourg administration with the task of carrying out on its behalf a construction programme that was defined piecemeal in the course of the years that followed. At the time, no contracts were concluded with the Luxembourg administration governing the financial arrangements for this programme or how it was to be monitored and audited.