, Special Report No 5/2000 on the Court of Justice's expenditure on buildings (annexe buil…

In forcesince 24 Feb 2000
9.

The Court of Justice put itself into a situation from which it was unable to extricate itself: as of September 1988, without first agreeing any lease, it went ahead with gradually occupying buildings for which it did not know the exact cost and where the financial conditions concerning its tenancy had been neither defined nor approved beforehand by the parties concerned

10.

Between 1989 and 1994, the Court of Justice, which was occupying the buildings without a lease, paid over LUF 1500 million (about ECU 35 million) by way of advances on rent payments to be adjusted. These amounts corresponded to the total budgetary appropriations available under the budget item "Rent". The Court of Justice's Financial Controller granted his approval to the commitment proposals and the corresponding payment orders even though these practices were irregular under the Community's Financial Regulation, which allows rent to be paid only on the basis of adequate supporting documents, in this case, a lease agreement.

11.

At the time, the Court of Justice was in the situation of renting and not yet of buying the buildings. Even though the Luxembourg administration clearly expressed its intention of setting the rent at a level sufficient to offset the construction costs(9), the amounts thus paid for the annexes were not fixed on the basis of a prior assessment, involving consultation of the parties concerned, of the true costs of each of the buildings, but in accordance with the amount asked for by the Luxembourg administration, whose requests the Court of Justice passed on to the Budgetary Authority. This being so, the amounts paid by the institution are not the result of verified economic parameters but mainly of the appropriations it was thought likely the Budgetary Authority would grant.

Agreement with a view to purchasing the buildings

Legal and financial aspects