, Special Report No 5/2000 on the Court of Justice's expenditure on buildings (annexe buil…

In forcesince 24 Feb 2000
12.

An Agreement was signed on 15 November 1994 between the Luxembourg administration and the Court of Justice whereby the Luxembourg administration rents out Annexes A, B and C to the Court of Justice, with a view to their purchase by the European Communities. The Agreement expires on the date on which the European Communities take over ownership of the buildings, at the latest in 2015. It can be revoked prior to that, in the event of the seat of the Court of Justice being moved outside Luxembourg by a decision taken on the basis of Article 289 of the EC Treaty. There are some grave inconsistencies in this Agreement. The Luxembourg administration undertakes to sell buildings which, at the time, it does not yet own. The Agreement also contains clauses(10) which derogate from ordinary law and are likely to do grave damage to the Communities' financial interests, and it is vague on the crucial matter of the arrangements for determining and checking the selling price.

13.

The financial arrangements made for building the annexes impose upon the Court of Justice the obligations of a borrower, without granting it the corresponding advantages in return (for example, ownership of the buildings thus financed). Formally, the intermediaries, the Luxembourg administration and the property developer, are legally responsible. However, they do not bear the cost of the commitments they have entered into. Quite apart from the fact that the Communities' Financial Regulation does not make any provision for having recourse to borrowing in order to make purchases of property, under such an arrangement the Communities are in the position of being unable to exercise any control over the financial costs they are obliged to bear, whatever their amount.