The Court of Justice launched and proceeded with this construction operation, which involved long-term financial obligations for the Communities, without first submitting it to its Financial Controller for examination. It also failed to inform the Budgetary Authority about the scale of the planned operations with a view to obtaining its prior authorisation.
The legal(4) and financial(5) arrangements agreed between the Court of Justice, the Luxembourg administration and the property developer, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the constructor, made it virtually impossible for the Communities to exercise technical and financial control over an operation for which, in the end, they would bear the final cost(6).
The whole programme was organised by the Luxembourg administration without abiding by the spirit of the Community procedures for public contracts(7). The invitation to tender was particularly limited. The constructor of Annexe A was chosen by means of a restricted invitation-to-tender procedure whereby the tenderers had only 20 days, in August 1985, to submit their bids. In 1989 when it came to building Annexe B and again in 1992 for Annexe C, the contract was awarded to the same constructor, without the contract being genuinely put out to tender.
Execution and occupation of the buildings
The conditions under which the buildings were constructed (adaptation to meet the Court of Justice's needs) and the cost of this work were directly affected by poor coordination and by the fact that the Court of Justice had little power to exercise any control during the course of the work (especially as regards the extra costs arising from putting right defects caused by bad workmanship and from design and execution errors).
The expenditure ceilings (totalling LUF 3940 million, inclusive of VAT, or about ECU 100 million) initially laid down by the laws(8) authorising the Luxembourg administration to have the annexes built were not complied with. The overall financial budget had to be increased, as of 1992, by LUF 740 million (about ECU 18 million) to cover the additional work requested by the institution, and also to cover the work on public roads and the remedying of bad workmanship, the cost of which looks likely to end up being borne by the Court of Justice.