Recital 35, Decision_act (EU) 1999/5

In forcesince 21 Dec 1998

The Commission has examined in detail all the information communicated by the Swedish authorities. This examination has led it to express reserves about the methodology chosen in order to estimate the high levels of consumption of foodstuffs likely to contain cyclamate. The Commission recognises the difficulties that the Member States have in monitoring consumption of food additives in order to estimate the high consumption levels that some population sub-groups may have. These difficulties have been analysed in detail in a report submitted to the Commission in January 1998 (15). This report indicates that in the case of an additive from a single source (one group of foodstuffs) high levels may be estimated by extrapolation on the basis of the average data available using the factor 3. However, according to this report the same method is inappropriate for calculating the intake of an additive from several combined sources (e.g. drinks, sweets and desserts). It is recognised that a consumer with a large consumption of foodstuff belonging to a particular group of foodstuffs cannot be considered statistically as consuming in the same way, i.e. substantially, foodstuffs belonging to other groups. It is therefore recommended in this report that an alternative statistical method should be used which does not run the risk of overestimating actual consumption levels. The Commission finds that this method was not used by the Swedish authorities, with the result that it has reservations about the figures submitted to it. However, above and beyond these considerations about extrapolation methods, the Commission wonders whether the figures put forward by the Swedish authorities are realistic. The statistical method used shows that there would seem to be a significant exceeding of the ADI in the case of diabetics and in particular diabetic children. The Commission is not convinced that these results, arrived at on the basis of statistics, are realistic. They do not take account of the fact that diabetics are a population sub-group who, more than any other consumers, attach particular importance to their diet, which in order to be balanced is in most cases the subject of medical supervision. Be that as it may, and whatever method is used, the data supplied by the Swedish authorities do not, in the Commission's opinion, show that the Swedish population or population sub-groups are in a specific situation compared with the populations of the other Member States with regard to this question of exceeding the cyclamate ADI.