Recital 23, Decision_act (EU) 1999/5

In forcesince 21 Dec 1998

The Commission considers that this does not in itself justify a total ban of the use of azo dyes in these non-prepackaged foodstuffs. The Commission would point out that measures other than prohibition can be carried out in conformity with existing Community legislation to settle this particular problem of foodstuffs offered for sale to the consumer without prepackaging. Article 12 of Directive 79/112/EEC provides that the Member States decide detailed rules for labelling these foodstuffs, such as the obligation to affix notices accompanying products sold in bulk and containing certain particulars on these products. Moreover, in order to inform all consumers fully about the content of certain foodstuffs Member States may require restaurants to include the list of ingredients on the menu. It is true that most of the time the consumers concerned are in fact children: the products in question are confectionery and non-alcoholic drinks which children tend to consume more often and in larger quantities than adults. Children cannot be considered to be 'consumers who are heedful of the composition of a product` within the meaning of the Court of Justice Decision of 26 October 1995 in Case C-51/94 (12). But the Commission thinks that the case of foodstuffs containing azo dyes and offered without prepackaging to children could also be resolved in a positive way instead of via prohibition. From the Swedish authorities' notification letter the Commission notes that children eat such confectionery at school. In the Commission's view Swedish schools, like the parents, could take care not to make available to allergic children products which are likely to give them allergic reactions. In school canteens, for instance, posting up the list of ingredients in food offered to children would allow an adult to check whether this list tallied with a list, drawn up by a doctor, of ingredients causing allergic reactions in the child concerned.

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 26 October 1995. Commission of the European Communities v Federal Republic of Germany.Decision

    26 Oct 1995 · 61994CJ0051

  • celex=31979L0112